Subscribe Now
2021 Pie
Editors’ Choice

Buttermilk Baking Co.


The pies at Buttermilk Baking Co. are what pie lovers dream of. Sky high apple, key lime with the perfect graham cracker crust, coffee caramel that will knock your socks off. Pie customization is available upon request, and they are now shipping pies nationally so everyone can enjoy your favorite flavor.

9 Liberty St., Newburyport, 978-499-8278,

Readers’ Choice

Agawam Diner


Loyal patrons of the Agawam Diner know first-hand how good the pie is. Whether you choose banana or chocolate cream, blueberry, cherry, or your favorite berry, you really can’t go wrong. The seasonal pumpkin and mince also are not to be missed.

166 Newburyport Tpke., Rowley, 978-948-7780,

All BONS 2021 Awards | Purchase BONS 2021 Issue | FAQ | 2020 Winners

Are you a BONS 2021 winner? Congratulations! Click here to get more out of your winner listing by viewing enhancement options, view our free downloadable assets and purchase winner merchandise.